Trimming Tango 2.0: The Great Perennial Pruning Party

Gloved hands pruning a plant with garden shears

Ever walk through your garden in September or October and notice your perennials looking a little… tired?

The Astilbe is slumped over. The Peony looks like it has had a very long week. The Rudbeckia is standing there with its seed heads looking like it just got back from a three-day music festival.

And your garden is basically whispering, “We could really use a haircut.”

You’re not wrong.

Fall is prime time to give many perennials a little cleanup before winter arrives in Northern Ohio. But before you grab the pruners and start hacking away like you’re clearing brush for a new driveway, let’s talk about who gets trimmed, who gets left alone, and who would prefer you mind your own business.

Because not every perennial wants the same treatment. Some want a full haircut. Some want a trim. Some want to keep their winter hairstyle. And a few are perfectly happy looking like they slept in their garden clothes all winter.

And here's some really good news: fall isn't just about pruning.

This is also a great time to divide and separate many spring- and summer-blooming perennials, lift and reset bulbs, and plant new perennials.

So while you're already wearing the gardening gloves, you might as well get some mileage out of them.

Welcome to Trimming Tango 2.0, where the plants lead and you try not to step on their toes.

Meet the Fab Four: The Personalities of Perennials

Every perennial has a personality.

Some are tidy. Some are wild. Some disappear completely. Others hang around all winter looking like they own the place.

To make fall cleanup easier, we’ve divided them into four groups.

1. Ground Huggers: The Disappearing Celebrities

Hosta, Phlox paniculata, Astilbe, Brunnera, Ferns, Liatris, Peonies, and many more

These are the garden’s professional escape artists.

Once winter settles in, many of them completely disappear, retreating underground until spring. Frankly, they have the right idea. While we're scraping ice off the windshield, they're sleeping peacefully beneath the soil.

You can cut these perennials back once the foliage has yellowed, browned or collapsed.

But don't get too enthusiastic.

If you cut everything down the minute the calendar says “fall,” you may accidentally create the perfect little winter resort for mice and other critters. Dense garden debris and freshly cleaned beds can become prime real estate for rodents looking for a warm place to spend the winter.

And here's another option: don't cut everything back.

Leaving some plants standing through winter provides food and shelter for birds and beneficial wildlife. Seedheads can become a backyard buffet, while dried foliage adds texture and interest to an otherwise very brown Northern Ohio winter landscape.

So if your garden doesn't look perfectly manicured in December, that's okay.

Mother Nature isn't running a golf course.

2. Rosette Romancers: The Drama Queens of the Garden

Asters, Achillea, Echinacea, Rudbeckia, Salvia, Coreopsis, Monarda, Lupines, and more

These are the plants that appreciate a little attention but don't necessarily need you to go overboard.

Cut many of these plants back to roughly 2–6 inches, leaving enough growth around the crown to provide some protection during winter.

Think stylish layered haircut—not military buzz cut.

Asters and Coneflowers are especially good examples. Their old flower heads can provide winter interest and food for birds, so there's no rule saying every last stem has to disappear before Thanksgiving.

In fact, sometimes the garden looks better when you leave a little personality behind.

If you do cut them back, however, removing dead or diseased foliage is always a good idea. You don't want old plant material becoming a winter storage locker for problems you'd rather not see next spring.

A little fall grooming now can mean healthier, better-looking plants when the growing season returns.

And after a Northern Ohio winter, everybody deserves a fresh start.

3. Semi-Evergreens: The Commitment-Phobes

Iris, Gaillardia, Geraniums, Dianthus, Scabiosa, Ajuga, Mums, and others

These plants can't quite make up their minds.

Are they evergreen?

Are they dormant?

Are they leaving for Florida?

Nobody knows.

Many semi-evergreen perennials benefit from a light cleanup rather than a complete demolition. Remove damaged, dead or declining foliage while leaving healthy growth in place.

Iris, for example, generally benefits from cleaning up dying leaves rather than chopping away every bit of green.

Gaillardia can get a quick cleanup to remove tired foliage and spent flower stems.

Dianthus and some hardy geraniums may keep attractive foliage well into winter, so don't automatically assume everything green needs to be cut down.

The rule here is simple:

If it still looks healthy, let it be.

Your pruners do not need to be involved in every conversation.

4. Evergreen Elite: The Year-Round Stunners

Lavender, Phlox subulata, Heuchera, Thyme, Oregano, Bergenia, Sedums, and more

These are the overachievers of the perennial world.

While everything else is collapsing into the ground, they are standing there saying, “Winter? That's cute.”

Many of these plants provide valuable winter structure and should generally be left alone.

Lavender can provide an attractive winter form. Heuchera keeps its foliage. Creeping Phlox adds evergreen interest. Bergenia can even develop beautiful winter coloration.

And Sedums?

Leave those seedheads standing and they can provide wonderful winter structure while giving birds something to investigate.

You may remove damaged or diseased material, of course, but don't feel compelled to give these plants a full haircut.

Sometimes the best pruning technique is putting the pruners back in the garage.

Divide and Conquer: Fall Is Prime Time for Perennial Division

Now let's talk about another fall garden job that doesn't get nearly enough attention: dividing your perennials.

Fall is a great time to divide and separate many spring- and summer-blooming perennials that have gotten too large, crowded or simply decided they would like to own the entire flower bed.

If a plant has become a giant mound, developed a dead or thin center, is crowding its neighbors or has simply outgrown its space, it may be time for a little separation.

Many established perennials can be lifted, divided and replanted in the fall, giving the divisions time to establish their roots before winter and put on new growth next spring.

Hostas, daylilies, peonies, iris and many other perennials can eventually become large enough that dividing them makes sense.

Just remember that not every perennial enjoys being divided at the same time, so know your plant before you start swinging the shovel.

And don't be afraid to make more plants.

That is one of the great benefits of dividing perennials. One crowded plant can become several healthy plants that can fill another bed, be moved to a new location or be shared with a gardening friend.

Because apparently gardeners have an uncontrollable urge to give other people plants.

We understand.

Bulbs: Lift, Reset and Get Them Ready for Another Show

Fall is also a great time to look at your spring bulbs.

If bulbs have become crowded, are planted too shallow or too deep, have stopped blooming well, or are simply growing somewhere they no longer belong, fall is a good time to lift and reset many spring-flowering bulbs.

Dig carefully, lift the bulbs, separate the offsets if appropriate, and replant them at the proper depth in well-drained soil.

This is also the time to plant new spring-flowering bulbs for next year's show.

Tulips, daffodils, hyacinths, crocus and many other spring bulbs need that period of cool soil to help prepare them for spring flowering.

So if your spring garden has been looking a little underwhelming, don't wait until April to complain about it.

April is too late.

Plant the bulbs now.

Your future self will appreciate it.

Mary's Magical Pruning Notes

Our resident garden guru, Mary, has a few additional tips for those who want to get their fall cleanup just right.

  • Baptisia, Hibiscus, Peony and Eupatorium: Cut back to approximately 5–9 inches for a neat finish.
  • Kniphofia: Let it do its disappearing act naturally. Hands off.
  • Lamium, Primula and Pulmonaria: Give them a light trim and a little compost. They'll appreciate the spa treatment.
  • Lamium and Ajuga: A light shear can keep them tidy, but don't scalp them. They like a little foliage left behind.
  • Upright Sedums: Cut back to the rosette when you're ready for cleanup.
  • Groundcover Sedums: Leave them alone and admire their work.
  • Sedum ‘Sieboldiana’: Treat it more like a tall Sedum and cut it back to the rosette.

And while you're already in the garden with your gloves on, don't forget the other jobs that sneak up on us every fall.

Bring in the Tropicals Before Jack Frost Does

If you have tropical plants, this is your reminder that “I'll bring it in tomorrow” is not a winterization plan.

Bring tropicals inside before freezing temperatures arrive.

This is also a great time to take cuttings of herbs such as rosemary, basil and oregano so you can continue growing and cooking with them indoors.

And if you've got bulbs that aren't hardy in our area, get those dug, dried and stored properly before the weather turns ugly.

Northern Ohio has a funny way of going from “This is pleasant” to “Why is there ice on my windshield?” in about twelve minutes.

It's Still a Great Time to Plant Perennials

And don't think that because summer is over, the planting season is over.

Fall is still a great time to plant perennials.

The soil is still warm, the brutal heat of summer has passed, and newly planted perennials have an opportunity to establish roots before winter arrives.

That means you can still add new plants to the landscape, fill those empty holes in the perennial border, replace something that didn't make it through summer or finally plant that perennial you've been thinking about since May.

The flowers may not be putting on the same show they did in June, but that doesn't mean the planting season is finished.

In fact, fall can be one of the nicest times to work in the garden.

The temperatures are cooler, the mosquitoes are becoming less enthusiastic about you, and you're no longer sweating through your shirt while trying to dig a hole.

That's progress.

Leave the Ornamental Grasses Alone—For Now

Here's one pruning job you should not rush.

Hold off on cutting ornamental grasses until after the first hard frost.

Their golden foliage and seedheads add beautiful movement and texture to the fall and winter landscape. They also provide shelter and habitat for wildlife.

Plus, let's be honest: when the rest of your garden is brown and flat, those tall grasses are doing a lot of heavy lifting.

Let them shine.

You can cut them back later in winter or early spring before new growth begins.

Compost Couture: Dress Your Garden Beds for Winter

Once you've finished your fall cleanup, consider adding a thin layer of compost or aged manure around your perennial beds.

Think of it as putting the garden to bed with a nice warm blanket—not burying it under a six-inch comforter.

Compost adds organic matter and nutrients while improving soil structure over time. And unlike a giant pile of mulch dumped directly onto the crowns of your plants, a properly applied layer of compost is a simple way to give your soil some attention before winter.

Just keep mulch and compost from being piled directly against plant crowns and stems.

Your plants want a blanket.

They do not want to be buried alive.

The Golden Rule of Fall Pruning

Here's the most important thing to remember:

You don't have to cut everything back.

Seriously.

We know. This is shocking information for people who enjoy a perfectly clean garden.

Some plants benefit from being cut back. Some look better and perform better when left standing. Some provide winter habitat and food for birds. And some simply don't need your help.

Before you make the first snip, identify the plant and know what it prefers.

And remember that fall gardening isn't just about pruning.

Divide those overgrown perennials. Lift and reset crowded bulbs. Plant new perennials. Clean up what needs cleaning up. Leave alone what should be left alone.

There is still plenty to do in the garden before winter locks the door.

The goal isn't to make your garden look like a freshly vacuumed living room in November.

The goal is to help your plants make it through winter healthy and ready to grow again next spring.

A Standing Ovation for Mary—and Jim

A big round of applause goes to Mary and Jim, our green-thumbed horticultural heroes, for helping keep Pandy's gardeners from committing unnecessary acts of pruning.

Their knowledge has helped countless gardeners understand that sometimes the best thing you can do for a plant is trim it, sometimes leave it alone, and sometimes just stop staring at it and let it grow.

So grab your pruners, your gloves, a shovel and maybe a cup of cider.

Take a walk through the garden.

Decide who's getting the haircut, who's getting a light trim, who's getting divided, which bulbs need to be lifted and reset, what new perennials need a home and who's getting to keep their winter hairstyle.

Then enjoy the crisp fall air while you can.

Because before long, we'll be standing outside in March staring at the thermometer, wondering why we ever thought gardening in Northern Ohio was a good idea.

And then April will arrive.

And we'll do it all over again.

That's gardening.

And frankly, we wouldn't have it any other way.


J.R. Pandy, "The No B.S. Gardener"
Pandy's Premier Garden Center
440-324-4314
www.pandysgardencenter.com

J.R. Pandy, The No B.S. Gardener

Photo by Jakub Żerdzicki on Unsplash

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.